American Gold Reserve Review

By Tim Schmidt - UPDATED: January 15, 2025

Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies listed on this page provide compensation to us. This is how we maintain our free service for consumers that visit us. Compensation & hard research determine where and how companies appear below.

Key Points

• Precious metals can be excellent options for strategic portfolio diversification, as they act as a hedge against inflation.
• Since American Gold Reserve offers different gold and silver products, it may be a convenient option for those who want to build a diversified precious metals portfolio.
• From personalized investment advice to different storage options, this precious metals dealer provides multiple services.
• While American Gold Reserve offers different products and personalized services, it's difficult to obtain clear information about its prices.
• This company has received mixed customer feedback. Most American Gold Reserve reviews show that some people think its products and services are quality, but others believe some areas need to be improved.
• Before you put your money into gold and silver products, you should compare different precious metals dealers, educate yourself about the market, and understand how your decisions can affect your current economic stability and financial future.

I personally put my money into the company I rated #1 after interviewing 100's of firms.  I found their customer service, offer, low fees, and buyback program were the best for my needs.

You can read my Goldco review here.

A Closer Look at American Gold Reserve

If you want to leverage what the precious metals market has to offer and are looking for a partner to start building an investment portfolio, American Gold Reserve will likely come your way more than once.

This dealer offers different products, including gold and silver coins, to those who see precious metals as suitable options to diversify and safeguard their money in periods of economic uncertainty.

But is it a legitimate company? Can you trust American Gold Reserve for your precious metals investments? Choosing a reliable provider is a big decision, and that's what I'll help you do today.

After years of evaluating American Gold Reserve and other precious metals dealers, I'm equipped with solid knowledge and comprehensive information to help you determine if this company is reliable or select one that aligns with your needs. Read on!

What You Should Know About Investing in Precious Metals

Before reviewing American Gold Reserve in depth, let's answer an important question: Why would you put your hard-earned money into precious metals?

Gold and silver have historically been attractive assets. Besides being highly coveted for their beauty, precious metals store value like very few other goods.

During periods characterized by market volatility, economic uncertainty, and inflation, gold and silver can help protect your wealth thanks to their intrinsic value and durability. Plus, their supply is relatively finite, and this scarcity helps maintain these advantages. That's why many choose precious metals as alternatives for savings and retirement portfolio diversification.

It's important to understand, however, that gold and silver investments won't make you rich overnight. This is a strategy that requires time, expertise, and thorough analysis. View precious metals as a way to preserve your wealth over time, not to make a lot of money quickly.

The Story Behind American Gold Reserve

American Gold Reserve has been doing business in the precious metals industry for several years. The company takes pride in offering high-quality products for different needs and exceptional customer service.

This dealer is also committed to transparency, promising customers to provide honest information every time. However, as I mentioned earlier, pricing details aren't readily available or accessible, which is something that many investors may see as a red flag.

The Core Offerings of American Gold Reserve

American Gold Reserve specializes in precious metals but focuses primarily on the two most popular options on the market: gold and silver.

Gold and Silver Product Selection

The company's precious metals selection includes several different products, including:

• Gold coins
• Silver coins
• Gold and silver bars
• Premium numismatic pieces

In other words, American Gold Reserve has something for every investor, whether you're a seasoned collector or are investing in precious metals for the first time. However, keep in mind that you must contact the dealer directly to get quotes and be able to compare prices, which can add complexity to the research and purchasing process.

Other Services Beyond the Purchase

Besides selling gold and silver coins, bars, bullion, and collectibles, American Gold Reserve offers tailored investment advice. You can get assistance from an experienced team to learn more about precious metals and make an informed decision about your investments.

This dealer also offers storage and delivery services, which means your assets will be kept safe in a specific location or securely transported to the required location after your purchase.

While these services show American Gold Reserve's commitment to customer satisfaction, I recommend speaking with the firm's representatives and asking all the questions you have in mind to understand all the key details before making your investments.

Areas for Improvement

All precious metals dealers, even the most reputable ones, can have their weaknesses and drawbacks. American Gold Reserve, for example, isn't as transparent as it should be when it comes to pricing.

While this doesn't seem like a big deal, this lack of transparency can make it challenging for investors to compare the company's products with what other dealers offer, which is something every investor should do before putting their money at risk.

Another clear weakness is the accessibility of the dealer's services. While the internet can facilitate transactions, and investors expect to purchase precious metals quickly in today's digital world, American Gold Reserve has a tedious purchasing process where potential buyers have to use different communication channels to obtain key information. This really affects the online experience.

In summary, these are my recommendations to improve American Gold Reserve's services and make this company more reliable and competitive in the precious metals market:

• Offer transparent information about prices and fees.
• Make the online purchasing experience more user-friendly.
• Provide more educational materials about precious metals investments, gold ownership, and other key topics to investors.

Comparative Analysis

If you want to know if American Gold Reserve is a reliable option, I recommend comparing this company to other major precious metals dealers. For example, some competitors are more transparent when it comes to pricing or offer more varied services, which is exactly what many investors are looking for.

American Gold Reserve vs. Other Precious Metals Dealers

When comparing American Gold Reserve to other precious metals dealers, you'll see that this company has two clear disadvantages: the lack of pricing transparency and a tedious online process.

Contrastingly, larger precious metals companies have better, more robust online platforms that facilitate online shopping and allow users to compare prices for different products, which are two important aspects for today's investors.

Besides that, American Gold Reserve may have a smaller product selection than competitors. Other dealers offer more gold and silver assets or even work with other precious metals, such as platinum and palladium. This is key for those focusing on portfolio diversification.

One clear advantage, however, is the company's personalized services, which can be particularly attractive to investors who chose a hands-on approach and can help American Gold Reserve stand out from competitors.

Unique Selling Points: What Sets American Gold Reserve Apart?

Although there are some weaknesses and drawbacks, American Gold Reserve can be attractive to some investors for different reasons.

The company's unique selling points include a strong commitment to customer service and personalized investment advice, which makes it an appealing option for newbies or people who need guidance throughout their investment experience.

Additionally, American Gold Reserve focuses on product quality and authenticity, which means that investors can be sure they'll receive genuine, high-value assets in their purchases.

Strategies for Investing

While investing in precious metals can be a good decision for many, it isn't just about buying gold and silver or purchasing assets and praying that their value holds up over time. You should have a strategy that considers key factors, such as your risk tolerance, and aligns with your needs.

Maximizing Your Precious Metals Portfolio

"Diversification" is a term you've probably heard if you want to maximize your investment portfolio. Essentially, this strategy focuses on spreading your money across multiple assets.

If you don't just focus on gold investment but put your money into other assets, including silver and other precious metals such as platinum and palladium, you can reduce your risks and potentially maximize your rewards.

Each precious metal performs in a specific way under different market conditions. While one loses value, another may experience a price increase. So, diversification can help you protect your wealth over the long term.

Choosing the Best Time to Buy Gold and Silver

Although you won't know exactly when the perfect time to buy an asset is, some signals can help guide your decisions. Keep in mind that timing is key for all investments, including precious metals.

For example, precious metals typically increase in value when there's economic instability or inflation rates go higher. These assets may perform better under such conditions, so you may want to consider adding them to your portfolio.

If the economy is strong and inflation starts to decline, other investment types may be better options, especially if you design a long-term strategy.

To get the best information, you should analyze your particular situation, the market, and the different investment options. Think about what makes sense in that specific economic scenario and design your strategy accordingly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you still have questions about American Gold Reserve, the products this company offers, or precious metals investments in general? I've created a comprehensive FAQ section with more information. Find it below!

Is American Gold Reserve Legit?

Yes, it is! American Gold Reserve is a precious metals dealer that has been in business for several years.

Although some reviews are negative or point out areas for improvement, this firm has built a solid reputation for offering quality items and valuable personalized services. However, I recommend doing your own research before making a decision.

How Does American Gold Reserve Ensure Product Quality?

American Gold Reserve sources gold and silver products from reputable mints and refineries, which has allowed this company to ensure that all available assets meet the highest quality standards.

Additionally, this dealer offers a guarantee of authenticity for all precious metals. In simple terms, each product you purchase undergoes a verification process to verify its purity and weight.

The company's dedicated customer service team can also help you address any concerns you may have about product quality.

If you have an issue to resolve, contact American Gold Reserve's representatives.

Is Investing in Precious Metals Risky?

All investments come with risks, and precious metals are no exception. Gold and silver can be affected by certain events, including market volatility, for example.

Precious metals prices can also fluctuate due to other reasons, such as economic events, changes in interest rates, and increases or decreases in currency values. Plus, physical assets must be stored and insured following certain rules, which can add to their cost.

Besides that, you should keep in mind that investing in precious metals doesn't offer interest or dividends like other investment products. If that's what you're looking for, it's important that you don't solely rely on gold or silver and that you consider portfolio diversification.

Can American Gold Reserve Help Me With My Retirement Plan?

American Gold Reserve offers certain products that may be suitable for retirement plans, including self-directed IRAs. Actually, precious metals can be good additions to your investment portfolio if you want to save for your future, as these assets can protect your wealth if the currency depreciates or inflation rises.

However, you should understand the requirements and regulations that your specific retirement plan may be subject to and choose an investment option accordingly. Here are my recommendations:

• Verify that American Gold Reserve's products meet the fineness and purity standards required for precious metals IRAs, as not all are eligible.
• Keep in mind that you'll need storage, so consider the options available for the assets that go into your IRA.
• Calculate the fees associated with opening an IRA, purchasing the required precious metals, and maintaining your account.

Does American Gold Reserve Buy Back Metals?

American Gold Reserve doesn't display information about a buy-back policy on its website, so you should contact the company directly to find out if this option is available.